DOES THAT MEAN I’M NOW A DITTOHEAD?
I never thought I would agree with Rush Limbaugh on anything. But it happened. In a radio broadcast last month the long-time loud voice of the far right said that, given the political split between Blue states and Red states, “secession might be inevitable.” True. I’ll go a step further and say secession is both unavoidable and desirable. These disunited United States are not just divided; we’ve downright splintered into at least six estranged and discrete culture blocs, one of which—the West states-- I discuss here. As Abraham Lincoln might have said, “A house splintered against itself, cannot stand.”
Rush went on to say “there cannot be a peaceful coexistence of two completely different theories of life, theories of government, theories of how we manage our affairs,” and he saw a “dire conflict” in the offing. Agree again. And I add my rising fear of our right-wing militias that threaten another civil war.
But Rush and I parted company when he said, “I see more and more people asking what in the world do we have in common with people who live in, say, New York?” Sorry, but the Empire State is a poor choice for comparison. The more obvious pick is the Golden State, where there is sporadic talk among Californians of going it alone as the fifth largest economic power in the world, where tolerance and science-propelled innovation give the world a preview of tomorrow. It’s still the Promised Land, where democracy blooms under an indulgent sun.
Donald J. Trump hates California and has waged war against it since taking office. He wants to build walls on our southern border, advise us on forest management, deny us sanctuary cities, defund our plans for a bullet train, undermine our bans on drilling for petroleum offshore and in the Central Valley, reverse our restrictions on automotive air pollutants, meddle in our politics—you name it, he’s there to trash us at every turn. Of course, sophisticated Californians call his every bluff and showed their disdain for the uncouth conman from Queens when at the polls, where last month they rejected him by a margin of 5,004,501 votes (64 percent to 34 percent spread). (In New York, Biden’s winning margin was a mere 1,833,217 votes, a 60 percent to 38 percent spread; but thanks for the opening to boast, Rush.)
Yes, California, the nation’s most diverse and populous state, could stand alone as a world power. But why think big when you can think bigger? Why not invite our cultural bedfellows—Oregon, Washington, and Hawaii, which share frontage with the mighty Pacific Ocean—to join us in showing the world how democracy is done? The so-called “Left Coast” states have already shown a unified commitment to fair and inclusive elections, unlike many of our corrupt Eastern states, where voter suppression is rampant, GOP gerrymandering is on steroids, and Black and brown voters face new obstacles every election season.
And yet we on the Left Coast help subsidize the taker states, sending more tax revenue to Washington, D.C., than we get back. Those dollars could be used to confront our own problems; we’ve got climate fires to fight, earthquakes to prepare for, long-term droughts to dampen, even volcanoes and tsunamis to dread. Those dollars, added to our united and optimistic mindset and energy, are needed to help us solve our problems, which can’t be can’t done as long as we remain in a polarized country that’s been deadlocked for 30 years.
Secession would be peaceful, of course. The other 46 states would remain our friends and trading partners. Why don’t we call our new nation “Pacifica” after our pacific exit from the “union” and in honor of the great ocean from which so many of our blessings come?
Those who doubt Pacifica’s viability should consider its component states’ cultural and political similarities over the last 40 years. Did you know that in this century, none of the four states has voted Republican for president? In fact, Washington, Oregon, and Hawaii haven’t gone Red since 1984 (36 years on the wagon); laggard California jumped aboard in 1988. Facts. Not the alternate kind.
And did you know that all four of the Pacific Coast states’ current governors are Democrats? The only two Republican governors since 2000 were California’s Arnold Schwarzenegger (2006-2010), at that a man too moderate for his fellow Republicans, and Hawaii’s Linda Lingle (2002–2010), the only Republican since 1962 (William F. Quinn) to fill that post in Hawaii.
The Left Coast’s liberal/progressive credentials are even more evident in the eight senators it sends to Washington, D.C. Yes, all are Democrats (four women and four men). This one-party dominance is nothing new. Hawaii hasn’t had a Republican senator since 1977 (Hiram Fong), Washington hasn’t had one since 2001 (T. Slade Gorton, III), Oregon hasn’t had one since 2009 (Gordon Smith), and California hasn’t had one since 1992 (John Seymour).
Perhaps most indicative of the Far West turn left is found in the growing number of House members each party sends to D.C.: Hawaii sends two Democrats and no Republicans, Washington sends seven Democrats and three Republicans, Oregon sends four Democrats and one Republican, and California sends 40 Democrats and 13 Republicans. That’s 53 Democrats and 17 Republicans, or 76 percent Blue and 24 percent Red—and that lopsided result comes without the “benefit” of the dark arts of gerrymandering so skillfully practiced by the GOP in North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Wisconsin, et al.
The West Coast liberal zeitgeist is apparent even in the seven House seats in California’s populous Orange County, long a secure bastion of ultra-conservatism in the Goldwater/Reagan/John Wayne West that was. Five of the seats are now occupied by Democrats ... such a nasty insult to the memory of John Birch.
And yet it is ironic that the Left Coast, with its liberal/progressive persuasion and direction, contributes mightily to the nation’s decades-long political paralysis. From 1988 to now, were you to subtract all of Pacifica’s electoral votes (presently 78) from the nation’s quadrennial presidential contest, the (alleged) United States would show its true color: a deep Red. That very thought should be Pacifica’s wake-up call. Yes, we are the outlier culture, tethered to those with whom we agree on very little.
Have you noticed that California Governor Gavin Newsom has since April of 2020 referred more than once in public address to California as a “Nation State”? And he speaks also of his close cooperation with Governors Kate Brown of Oregon and Jay Inslee of Washington in combating the COVID-19 pandemic on a “regional” basis? Portents of things to come? The Left Coast nation Pacifica in embryo?
Let’s take the present national paralysis as our cue to break away and start anew. Let’s begin by calling for our own constitutional convention (in Honolulu?) to set the rules we will live by. Use the 1789 document as our template, update it in a few outdated places, and patch up the many tears the lawless Trump Administration left for the world to see. Those states left behind can do the same, creating their own nation-states closer to the hearts’ desires of their citizens ... done peacefully as free members of a loose and congenial confederation.
Pacifica’s first president? Easy choice. Barack Obama. He’s rested and ready ... and a native son.
We can do this now voyagers, fellow lovers of democracy! And thanks for the push, Rush.